One of Philosophy’s Most Influential Public Voices May Lose His Own


“Basically, the parts of my brain that tell my mouth how to produce speech are gradually shutting down. Over time my speech is likely to worsen, and eventually I may not be able to speak at all.”

That is John Corvino, professor of philosophy (and former dean of the honors college) at Wayne State University, in a public social media post in which he shares that he was diagnosed with an unusual neurodegenerative disorder, Primary Progressive Apraxia Of Speech (PPAOS), which is resulting from FrontoTemporal Degeneration (FTD) in the right front lobe of his brain.

The problem was discovered by a PET scan earlier this year.

Here’s how he describes the condition:

Basically, the parts of my brain that tell my mouth how to produce speech are gradually shutting down. Over time my speech is likely to worsen, and eventually I may not be able to speak at all. It’s not the more common Primary Progressive Aphasia (PPA, what Bruce Willis has); I have no trouble with word recall or comprehension. It’s a motor-speech problem, not a language problem, fortunately. Even when I speak relatively normally, as I often can, it takes considerable concentration to produce smooth speech. The best I can describe it is that it feels like I’m saying tongue twisters, even when I’m saying things that should be easy for me to say. And that concentration leaves little bandwidth for figuring out what to say, so I sometimes come across as reticent and inarticulate.

It is hard to think of another philosopher of this era who has so consistently and effectively used his voice to bring philosophy to the public, in a principled manner and as a force for good, as John Corvino.

Corvino is known for his work in ethics and social and political philosophy, and especially for his work on homosexuality and same-sex marriage, and religious liberty. He is the author of What’s Wrong with Homosexuality? and Debating Same-Sex Marriage (with counterpoint by Maggie Gallagher), among other works, including the widely anthologized essay, “Why Shouldn’t Tommy and Jim Have Sex?”

Over the past two decades, Professor Corvino has engaged in over 80 public conversations or debates, mainly on the topic of homosexuality, same-sex marriage, religion, and other issues that arise in the “culture wars.” He has also delivered countless lectures on these topics at campuses and other venues, bringing arguments and perspectives about these topics to audiences often not accustomed to reasoning about them. An out gay man defending homosexuality against charges of immorality and arguing in favor same-sex marriage, Corvino has not shied away from bringing debate about these topics to some of the most conservative places in the country.

John Corvino (still image from one of his public philosophy videos)

He has spoken on CNN, ABC, FOX, C-SPAN, MSNBC, and other television networks, as well as radio. He also created several well-crafted series of videos, each with tens of thousands of views. They are available on YouTube. One of these is a 13-part series, “Better Argument with John Corvino,” in which he shares advice about reasoning in quick, informative, and amusing segments.

“Better argument” is a topic that Corvino is eminently qualified for, not just because he is a philosophy professor, but because he is someone who has consistently embodied virtuous reasoning in debate with others over topics not just of professional interest but personal importance, addressing not just hostile but at times hateful audiences. In person and on the screen, he is a gifted communicator who knows the value of engaging with “the other side” and knows that such engagement, to be effective, requires understanding and honesty.

Of his medical condition, Professor Corvino says, “I’m sharing this news publicly to raise awareness about PPAOS and FTD, and also to let friends who haven’t seen me in a while know that, if you bump into me and I seem awkward in conversation, the problem isn’t you.”

He adds:

I still enjoy writing, which is unaffected by the PPAOS. I am finishing up my book project on political polarization, civility, and free speech for Oxford University Press (stay tuned!), and I’ve begun work on a memoir. I never thought my life was interesting enough for a memoir, but for someone who once had a thriving public speaking career to develop a rare neurodegenerative condition that targets speech—let’s just say that I’ve found my “hook.”

Corvino’s Facebook post about his condition is here.

guest

9 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Victor Caston
Victor Caston
10 months ago

Awful to learn, but I admire your courage and strength. May your mind stay clear and words still flow through your pen.

Last edited 10 months ago by Victor Caston
Eva Dadlez
10 months ago

I am very sorry to hear this. I met you perhaps thirty years ago at the Mountain-Plains Philosophy Conference in Santa Fe, when I commented on your splendid Hume paper. The organizing committee, as I recollect, was in awe of the felicity and brilliance of your prose as well as your presentation. Your words will make a lasting impression whatever the mode of delivery.

Jason Swartwood
10 months ago

John is one of my philosophical heroes. Few have done more in the last few decades to demonstrate the power of Philosophy to contribute to productive thinking about moral questions and productive discussion with those with whom we disagree. Best wishes as you navigate this, John.

SHELLEY LYNN TREMAIN
SHELLEY LYNN TREMAIN
10 months ago

Hello, John Corvino,

We have never met, but I have admired your work. I am relatively confident that I am one of the only philosophers who can assume to know the texture and vicissitudes of some of your current experiences with respect to speech. My remarks in response to your news will thus depart from the many comments that you have received in various venues.

I hope that soon you will come to recognize yourself as a disabled person, where that designation should be understood as a political and social position and identity. As a disabled person with your training, political insight, and privileged social status, you have remarkable opportunities to learn from and reflect upon the lessons of other disabled people about the oppression and social injustice that we encounter on a daily basis, publicly, professionally, culturally, domestically, and so on.

The writing of disabled philosophers and other disabled authors can guide you to marginalized philosophical perspectives on and understandings of your social and phenomenological experiences and situation (and the social situation of other disabled people) that challenge medicalized approaches to them. You have remarkable opportunities to draw the connections between, on one side, your previous work on social justice for LGBTQ communities and, on the other, social justice for disabled communities, as well as to thus contribute to social and institutional change for disabled philosophers and disabled people throughout society.

Yours in struggle,
Shelley Tremain

Patrick Lin
Reply to  SHELLEY LYNN TREMAIN
10 months ago

If we’re lucky to live long enough, we’ll all be disabled.

So, it makes perfect sense to advocate for—or at least support or learn aboutthose interests now. If it’s not already a current interest for you (or your family and friends), it will be eventually.

Nicolas Delon
Nicolas Delon
10 months ago

John spoke at a panel on the norms of discussion at the APA in New York in January. He mentioned his developing issue and apologized for reading his paper and only being able to give terse answers. But he gave one of the most beautiful papers I had heard in a long time. Your courage and grace are a model for us all. We will keep listening and reading.

Daniel Propson
10 months ago

John, thank you for your mentorship, your compassion, your clarity of thought, and your basic decency. I look forward to this new chapter. And I definitely look forward to the memoir, which I imagine (knowing you) will be filled with plenty of delightful wordplay about losing your voice, as well as finding it.

Tim Kirschenheiter
Tim Kirschenheiter
10 months ago

John is the best. As my professor, dissertation adviser, and now friend, he has taught me more about being a teacher and philosopher than anyone else has.

It breaks my heart to imagine that our most recent conversation might be our last. But I know that John will make the best out of this awful diagnosis.

Kellye Rose
Kellye Rose
5 months ago

John — I am one of a group of people diagnosed with PPAOS that meets every 2 weeks, on Zoom on Sunday afternoon, to talk amongst ourselves (as we can!) and give support to each other. We’d love to have you join with us, as well as any others you may have met with PPAOS.