News for & about the philosophy profession

Latest Comments

  1. David Merry on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    I guess I’m yet to be convinced AI is good enough at literature searches to replace philpapers etc. Am I an outlier here?

  2. A PHILOSOPHER NAMED SLICKBACK on New: “(Æ)Lab:999”

    NO! It is "A PHILOSOPHER NAMED SLICKBACK," like "A TRIBE CALLED QUEST"; you say the whole thing.

  3. Felix on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    To me, it being AI exacerbates the exhaustion a fair amount, largely because it almost entirely eliminates the human element of it, and certainly undermines the educational purpose…

  4. Alm on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    In three years graduating HS students will basically be AI experts. They won't curtail use to appease luddite professors, they will just find a different major or school.…

  5. AGT on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    I have no problem with the policy as an honor code since an honor code is not a policy.

  6. Derek Baker on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    Why are these important skills? They were. Being able to operate MS DOS was once an important skill.

  7. Derek Baker on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    This fits with what historians say about cultural traditions in general.

  8. Mike on the Internet on New: “(Æ)Lab:999”

    Can we just just call you "Slickback" for short?

  9. Meme on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    Ahhhh, lol I get it now, I was just totally misreading the string of comments. I first thought you were correcting Grant, and then I thought (for some…

  10. A PHILOSOPHER NAMED SLICKBACK on New: “(Æ)Lab:999”

    If the journal chooses to go with the cover, I must say, then it's one of the most aesthetic covers in the game. Might submit just for that…

  11. Michel on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    Uh… When I say 'chime', I'm saying I agree with what grant said. It's like saying 'ditto' or 'what s/he said'.

  12. Louis F. Cooper on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    I think it goes back to the original comment (i.e., by "Grad student") and the reference to the ban sweeping in use of the spell-checker. "Learning to spell…

  13. Kenny Easwaran on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    "The traditional way" being the way we started doing it about 10-15 years ago, when Google, SEP, and PhilPapers were well-established!

  14. Kenny Easwaran on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    I actually think it's better to have a bold and improperly defended thesis than it is to have such a policy! A policy actually affects people's lives, and…

  15. Kenny Easwaran on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    The way I see it would be if some faculty member decided in future that they wanted to incorporate some AI use in their class, but the policy…

  16. Kenny Easwaran on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    Checking for cogency wasn't mentioned – he just mentioned checking for comprehensibility, and checking for possible flaws. It really is hard to know if your own writing is…

  17. Kenny Easwaran on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    But it also doesn't seem to difficult to find a situation where five philosophers are extremely anti-AI and one is open to using it, but decides to go…

  18. Kenny Easwaran on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    Yes, it's pretty easy to enforce policies against AI-generated text in final submissions! But it's pretty hard to enforce policies banning students from ever discussing their class readings…

  19. grant on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    Ultimately, we wanted to avoid having six different AI policies that contradict each other.  My understanding is that they considered it. But it is too complicated and vague,…

  20. Kenny Easwaran on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    You really don't have a problem banning people from talking to their phone to set a reminder for a due date, or using smart select to copy images…

  21. Kenny Easwaran on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    This is basically a terminological question – does "AI" apply to all computerized uses of data to make improved decisions about what text to display, or only to…

  22. Eric Steinhart on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    "Currently, at least, it applies to all of the philosophy faculty."

  23. grant on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    Maybe I misunderstood something but don't most similar policies/bans have exceptions, such as, animals are banned in this space (e.g. library) except for service animals? We do not…

  24. Jimmy Alfonso Licon on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    That argument proves too much, but okay lol

  25. David Wallace on Philosophy Department Bans AI Use

    I’m not convinced this is an optimal policy (certainly it’s more restrictive than Pitt HPS’s policy) but I applaud the decision to think through and work out some…