Journal of the History of Philosophy 2023 Book Prize


The Journal of the History of Philosophy (JHP) has announced the winner of its 2023 Book Prize.

The prize, awarded for the best book written in history of philosophy published in 2022, went to Stephen Ogden (Notre Dame) for his book, Averroes on Intellect: From Aristotelian Origins to Aquinas’s Critique (Oxford University Press, 2022).

According to the publisher,

Averroes on Intellect provides a detailed analysis of the Muslim philosopher Averroes (Ibn Rushd)’s notorious unicity thesis — the view that there is only one separate and eternal intellect for all human beings. It focuses directly on Averroes’ arguments, both from the text of Aristotle’s De Anima and, more importantly, his own philosophical arguments in the Long Commentary on the De Anima.

Stephen Ogden defends Averroes’ interpretation of De Anima using a combination of Greek, Arabic, Latin, and contemporary sources. Yet, Ogden also insists that Averroes is not merely a ‘commentator’ but an incisive philosopher in his own right. The author thus reconstructs and analyzes Averroes’ two most significant independent philosophical arguments, the Determinate Particular Argument and the Unity Argument. Alternative ancient and medieval views are also considered throughout, especially from two important foils before and after Averroes, namely, Avicenna (Ibn Sina) and Thomas Aquinas. Aquinas’ most famous and penetrating arguments against the unicity thesis are also addressed. Finally, Ogden considers Averroes’ own objections to broader metaphysical views of the soul like Avicenna’s and Aquinas’, which agree with him on several key points including the immateriality of the intellect and the individuation of human souls by matter, while still diverging on the number and substantial nature of the intellect.

The central goal of this book is to provide readers with a single study of Averroes’ most pivotal arguments on intellect, consolidating and building on recent scholarship and offering a comprehensive case for his unicity thesis in the wider context of Aristotelian epistemology and metaphysics.

Previous winners of the JHP book prize are listed here.

 

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

2 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Martin Lenz
6 months ago

This is a really great study – congratulations!

Kelly Weirich
Kelly Weirich
6 months ago

Congrats, Stephen!