this reads as “I’m in a profession that ostensibly questions the foundations of everything, ever, but I struggle accepting the outcome of a democratic process and the reality of what half of my country thinks.”
That’s an interesting “read”, but one thing really has nothing to do with the other. Sometimes democratic processes produce very bad results that are difficult to accept – even for people in professions that ostensibly question the foundations of everything.
If you take the people in the cartoon to represent Americans in general, then yes, some of them should be happy instead of despondent. But these could just be a collection of liberals who have gone to the railroad tracks to commit suicide. You will agree that a lot of liberals aren’t happy right now. I know I’m not. (The issue of whether we ought to be depressed or not seems beside the point, unless I’m misreading the cartoon and it is depicting (with comedic exaggeration) how we should be acting now. I read it as saying, “a lot of people are despondent right now”.
Alan White
6 years ago
I love this cartoon, in the best tradition of ingenious conceptual inversion.
And I just love John Lewis for his stance this past weekend, and not merely based on his real-life moral authority to criticize Trump. Trump won by three states’ electoral votes representing a total of 0.066% (80k out of 120m total votes) of the electorate, and though I’m no statistician, I suspect a case could be made that, except for the interloping of the Russians, abetted by Comey, Trump could not have won. Gotta love those close world counterfactuals! And let the threaded-blood-letting begin, as is inevitable.
…okay.
this reads as “I’m in a profession that ostensibly questions the foundations of everything, ever, but I struggle accepting the outcome of a democratic process and the reality of what half of my country thinks.”
That’s an interesting “read”, but one thing really has nothing to do with the other. Sometimes democratic processes produce very bad results that are difficult to accept – even for people in professions that ostensibly question the foundations of everything.
https://twitter.com/ddale8/status/821012282872307712/photo/1?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw
That quote/answer alone is reason to be despondent about the fact that Trump will actually be the president.
If you take the people in the cartoon to represent Americans in general, then yes, some of them should be happy instead of despondent. But these could just be a collection of liberals who have gone to the railroad tracks to commit suicide. You will agree that a lot of liberals aren’t happy right now. I know I’m not. (The issue of whether we ought to be depressed or not seems beside the point, unless I’m misreading the cartoon and it is depicting (with comedic exaggeration) how we should be acting now. I read it as saying, “a lot of people are despondent right now”.
I love this cartoon, in the best tradition of ingenious conceptual inversion.
And I just love John Lewis for his stance this past weekend, and not merely based on his real-life moral authority to criticize Trump. Trump won by three states’ electoral votes representing a total of 0.066% (80k out of 120m total votes) of the electorate, and though I’m no statistician, I suspect a case could be made that, except for the interloping of the Russians, abetted by Comey, Trump could not have won. Gotta love those close world counterfactuals! And let the threaded-blood-letting begin, as is inevitable.